The WSJ is dead to me.

Nice.  Nobody who had actually READ Tangerine would EVER put it in the same category as All's Fair in Love, War and High School. 

(I've actually read both, so I feel comfortable voicing my opinion. Tangerine is FANTASTIC, while All's Fair is just a cute -- but not overly impressive -- chick-lit-ish light read.)

It really ticks me off when people shoot off their mouths about J/YA books when it's clear that they haven't read anything that's come out (with the possible exception of HP) in the last twenty-five years.

(via Jen Robinson, who also links to Shannon Hale's rant about the piece)